Home » News » How Do You Sell a Crime Scene House in Florida?

Mastering the Market: How Do You Sell a Crime Scene House in Florida?

crime scene home 1000px

Selling a crime scene house in Florida entails special considerations from disclosure to deal closure. This no-nonsense guide cuts through the uncertainty, delivering the insights you need on Florida’s legal landscape and offering pragmatic solutions for the clean-up, presentation, and negotiation stages. Equip yourself with the knowledge on how do you sell a crime scene house in Florida, to tackle the sale of a crime scene property in a straightforward and legally savvy manner.

Key Takeaways

  • Florida law does not require sellers to disclose a property’s history of homicide, suicide, or other deaths, but sellers are advised to disclose all material facts to avoid potential legal issues.
  • Preparing a crime scene house for sale includes detailed cleaning, repairs, professional staging, and mitigation of past events to make the house appealing and safer for potential buyers.
  • Marketing a crime scene house for sale involves striking a balance between transparency about the property’s past and reinforcing its current and future potential, often with the help of a real estate agent experienced in stigmatized properties.

Understanding Florida’s Disclosure Laws


Florida law requires sellers to disclose significant information that might affect a property’s value to potential purchasers. Notably, events like homicide or suicide on a property are not required to be disclosed under Florida Statute 689.25. In addition to these unique rules, sellers must also disclose specific information regarding:

  • homeowners’ association membership
  • radon gas
  • coastal erosion
  • lead-based paint, if applicable.

Material Facts

Material facts in Florida’s real estate realm are defined as facts that significantly impact a property’s value, are known by the seller, and are unknown to the buyer. To facilitate this disclosure process, realtors use a Seller’s Property Disclosure form.

Sellers are advised to disclose all relevant material facts, even those the buyer may already know, to prevent possible legal issues.

Non-Disclosure Consequences

Interestingly, the state law in Florida provides protection to property owners and agents from civil cases for not disclosing a property’s history of:

  • homicide
  • suicide
  • natural death
  • deaths
  • HIV/AIDS infection status of occupants

Additionally, they are not denied access to legal protection in these situations.

This legal nuance, often involving a court order, is part of what makes selling a crime scene house in Florida a unique endeavor.

Preparing the Crime Scene House for Sale

very clean house 1000px

Once the relevant laws are understood, it’s time to get the crime scene house ready for sale. Comprehensive interior updates can mitigate the impact of a crime that occurred on the property. But how exactly do you achieve this? The process involves thorough cleaning and repairs, professional staging, and addressing any claims of paranormal activity.

Thorough Cleaning and Repairs

Ensuring the complete removal of hazardous materials such as blood and bodily fluids is a fundamental step in addressing the property’s safety and aesthetic concerns. Hiring professionals specialized in crime scene cleanup is critical to meticulously address the scene, including:

  • Removing all traces of blood and bodily fluids
  • Disposing of biohazardous waste properly
  • Sanitizing and deodorizing the affected areas
  • Potentially replacing large items like furniture or carpets

The cost of cleaning a crime scene can fluctuate greatly, based on the intricacy of the work and the need for material removal and replacement.

Professional Staging

Professional staging, especially for crime scene houses, can transform the space into a neutral and appealing environment, shifting potential buyers’ focus away from the property’s history. By hiring a professional stager, you can:

  • Present the property in the most attractive way possible
  • Enhance the presentation and perception of the house
  • Increase the likelihood of a quicker sale
  • Negotiate more favorable terms

Addressing Paranormal Activity Claims

It’s also important to address any claims of paranormal activity. In many states, disclosing such activity is not mandatory. However, being upfront about these claims can help alleviate any potential buyer concerns.

Marketing the Crime Scene House

laptop listing

After the house is ready, marketing becomes the subsequent step. Marketing a crime scene house requires a fine balance between transparency and sensitivity in showcasing the property’s history. Effective marketing also involves identifying the right buyer demographic and using precise language to target these groups.

Collaborating with a real estate agent experienced in handling the sale of stigmatized properties can be a valuable asset in navigating this complex process.

Targeted Advertising

A targeted advertising strategy for a crime scene house should focus on buyer demographics that appreciate the uniqueness of the property and look beyond its stigma. Some buyers may perceive a crime scene house as a valuable investment opportunity due to the potential for lower prices and reduced competition in the market.

Transparency in Marketing Materials

Transparency is a key factor in marketing materials for a crime scene house. Being honest with potential buyers about the house’s history is crucial. However, it’s equally important to highlight the positive features of the property’s current state and emphasize its future potential.

Collaborating with a Knowledgeable Realtor

Working with a realtor experienced in managing stigmatized properties, such as crime scene houses, is crucial for effectively navigating both the emotional and practical challenges of such sales. A knowledgeable realtor can offer invaluable guidance and support throughout the process.

Navigating the Sales Process

affordable home small

Having covered the preparation and marketing stages, it’s time to explore the sales process. Key aspects to consider during this phase include setting a realistic price, handling buyer questions, and seeking legal assistance to ensure all disclosure and legal requirements are met.

Pricing Strategy

Setting a price for a crime scene house requires careful consideration. Stigmatized properties can be valued at 10% to 25% less than similar market properties, and typically experience a decrease in value for a few years following the incident. The impact of violent death on property values can result in a drop in rental prices of nearby units by about 10% immediately after the event. However, this effect tends to diminish after 7-8 years.

With this in mind, adjusting the asking price should reflect both the psychological impact and potential impact on future resale value, considering the stigma attached to the property.

Handling Buyer Questions

Readiness to answer buyer inquiries about the crime is another crucial element in selling a crime scene house. Providing before and after photos of the crime scene cleanup can substantiate the restoration and visually demonstrate to buyers the changes made. These photos, along with other physical evidence such as testimonials from cleanup professionals or prior occupants, can act as a form of social proof to further alleviate buyer anxieties about the property’s past.

Legal Assistance

Lastly, consulting a real estate attorney can assist in understanding the complexities of selling a stigmatized property, guaranteeing compliance with all disclosure and legal obligations. These attorneys also have the authority to initiate civil action on behalf of the seller if there is an issue with full disclosure to potential buyers, which can lead to settlements in favor of the affected party.

Alternative Options for Crime Scene Houses

woman checkmarks

While selling a crime scene house is certainly a viable option, there are alternatives to consider. These alternatives encompass renting, renovating or rebuilding the property. These alternatives can provide income for the owner, lessen the immediate impact of the stigma, and offer a fresh start for the property.

Renting the Property

Renting out stigmatized properties can lessen the immediate impact of the stigma associated with the property. Leasing out the property may provide income for the owner, serving as a financial cushion during the time it takes for the stigma to fade.

Over time, the negative associations of a crime scene house can diminish, reducing the stigma as memories fade and new experiences overshadow past events. This can lead to an increase in the property’s value over time, offering the potential for a better price point in the future.

Renovating or Rebuilding

Renovating or rebuilding is another alternative for crime scene properties, including abandoned property. Such properties can be creatively repurposed for new uses, such as educational facilities or community centers. For example, the University of Idaho chose to demolish a house on their property following multiple murders, eradicating the stigma associated with the crime scene.

Florida Case Studies

contract 1

To demonstrate the possibilities for successful sales and innovative use of crime scene houses, a few Florida case studies involving violent crimes will be examined.

Successful Sales

Murder houses in urban areas of Florida are generally more likely to regain their full market value, especially compared to rural areas. The Chi Omega sorority house in Florida, a notable crime scene from Ted Bundy’s crimes, has been valued at $191,600, demonstrating potential market value retention. In this context, the term “murder house” refers to a property where a murder has occurred.

With effective disclosure, remodeling, and possibly changing the address or telephone number, such properties can still be sold successfully.

Creative Repurposing

In addition to successful sales, crime scene properties can also be creatively repurposed. A house in St. Paul that was once a crime scene has been transformed into a lab for criminal investigation and death investigation courses at Hamline University, serving as a valuable resource for a law enforcement agency.

These annual events provide students with practical experience and give the property a new purpose.


In conclusion, selling a crime scene house in Florida is a complex process requiring a deep understanding of disclosure laws, meticulous preparation, strategic marketing, and careful navigation of the sales process. However, with the right approach, even stigmatized Florida properties can find a new purpose and potential buyers.

Whether you decide to sell, rent, or repurpose a crime scene house, remember that every property has the potential for a fresh start. With transparency, creativity, and a bit of patience, these houses can overcome their dark histories and step into a brighter future.

Frequently Asked Questions

question mark

Are sellers required to disclose a property’s history of homicide or suicide in Florida?

No, sellers in Florida are not required to disclose a property’s history of homicide or suicide. This is based on Florida Statute 689.25.

How should I price a crime scene house?

When pricing a crime scene house, consider the psychological impact and potential impact on future resale value due to the stigma attached to the property. This will help ensure a fair and reasonable price.

How can I prepare a crime scene house for sale?

To prepare a crime scene house for sale, focus on thorough cleaning, repairs, professional staging, and addressing any claims of paranormal activity. These steps can help make the property more attractive to potential buyers.

What are some alternative options if I don’t want to sell my crime scene house?

Consider renting the property, renovating, or repurposing it for a different use such as an educational facility or a community center. These are alternative options to selling your crime scene house.

Do I need a realtor to sell my crime scene house?

Working with a realtor experienced in managing stigmatized properties can offer invaluable guidance and support when selling a crime scene house, though it’s not mandatory.